If you’re asking, you should probably start with the Sampler: it’s got something for everyone, and that way you can pick your favorite for yourself.
If you want to start with just one flavor, take the quiz below to decide what yours might be:
It's 3 PM. You're hungry. What do you actually want?
1. A sharp piece of cheddar and a cracker
2. Cold leftover pizza, no shame
3. Something with kick: a slice of pepperoni, a spicy pickle, hot sauce on whatever's around
4. All of the above, simultaneously, while standing in front of the fridge
 
On a scale of "ranch dressing" to "Carolina Reaper," where are you?
1. Ranch dressing. I like flavor, not pain
2. Sriracha on most things, hot honey on the rest
3. I keep a bottle of habanero hot sauce in my bag at all times
4. Depends on the day: I match the heat to my mood
 
What was your favorite snack to find in your lunchbox as a kid?
1. Goldfish
2. Combos
3. Takis
4. I packed my own because I always wanted something different
 
Count your answers.
 
Score 3-5: go with White Cheddar. 6-8: Cheese Pizza. 9-10: Pepper Jack. 11-12: we still think you should start with the Sampler, you’re not a one-flavor person.